Saturday, June 30, 2018

Saturday Evening Cartoons: Superman, Volume 3: Multiplicity

     Superman, Volume 3: Multiplicity collects three different stories. The first is a crossover with Swamp Thing from the first Superman Annual. Being a Swamp Thing story, this gets pretty tripy at times. It starts with the fields around Superman's farm dryin up. After some fruitless investigation, Swamp Thing shows up. He believes that Superman is causing a disturbance in The Green because their is some kind of anomaly between him and the earth. He offers to cleanse Superman but Clark is initially reluctant and the two (of course) end up fighting. In the end Superman sees reason and allows himself to be "bonded" with Swamp Thing, who fixes the anomaly through some scientific mumbo jumbo. The artwork by Jorge Jiménez, Alejandro Sanchez is really beautiful, though there is some inconsistent facial work. The story, unfortunately, isn't great. There is simply no reason for the fight between Superman and Swamp Thing, so the whole thing feels contrived and, in the end, anti-climatic.

     The main story collected is Multiplicity, sees Superman get mixed up with the Justice League Incarnate, a multiversal (is that a word?) version of the Justice League created by Grant Morison for his Multiversity miniseries. The story begins with Clark meeting Red Son Superman, who warns him that someone called Prophecy is coming before being attacked by an army of humanoids called the Gatherers. He then overhears that the Gatherers are planning to capture Kenan Kong, the Superman of China.

     It turns out that Prophecy is trying to capture Supermen throughout the multiverse who are on his "Lyst." After defeating the Gatherers, Clark and Red Son Superman are met by the Justice League Incarnate who are also investigating Prophecy and the disappearance of the Supermen. Clark decides to team up with them to stop Prophecy. They travel to the various earth's to try and warn the Supermen there before they are captured but the Gatherers keep thwarting them so Superman comes up with a plan to take the fight to Prophecy. He allows himself to be captured so the League can track him to Prophecy's location.

     This story is delightfully absurd. Superman uses music (yes music!) to lead the Justice League International to Prophecy and he and the other heroes get some really inspiring moments. I can't compare it to Multiversity as I didn't read that book, but I am guessing that it is far less meta then Morrison's story. For me, this is a good thing. I don't want a lot of self aware weirdness invading my Superman book. Multiplicity also includes some set up for later on as we learn that Prophecy was capturing the Superman in order to take their power for himself so that he can stop a greater looming threat that he knows is coming.

     This arc was drawn by like six different artists including Ivan Reis (on #14), Clay Mann on (#15 and 16), Ryan Sook, Ed Benes, and Jorge Jiménez (all on #15) and Tony S. Daniel (on #16). Because of this the art is kind of all over the place but they sort of make it work by having different artist tackle different Earths in the multiverse. I still found the radically different art styles from page to page a bit distracting though.
     The final story is a one-shot entitled "Dark Harvest" which sees Jon and his friend Kathy Branden search for her grandfather, who has gone after their prize cow Bessie who went missing in the woods. There, they run into some increasingly bizarre situations and are followed by a mysterious dark man, who at one point grows giant and tries to catch them. They are saved by Mr. Branden, who has found Bessie after a long search. He assumes that something in the swamps waters must have caused them to hallucinate.

     The art by Sebastian Fiumara with colors by Rob Stewart is really quite strong and has a harsh, sketchy quality that really fits the tone of this story. They do some really cool things with perspective for the more trippy, hallucinatory scenes and the use of light and shadow is really effective. This story reads like something you'd release in October despite it's April release date. It's sufficiently mysterious and creepy but there's little in the way of character growth or real drama, which is unfortunately true about all the stories in this volume.

     I think DC's twice-a-monthly shipping schedule hurt a lot of there rebirth titles and it definitely shows here. We spend most of this volume dragging our feet and teasing the larger story without moving it forward. With that said I think that Tomasi and Gleason's characterization of Superman is still spot on. There's a moment in the Multplicity story where he tells Kenan Kong, "it’s in places like this that hope burns brightest.” That's Superman. He also does a good job portraying the family dynamics between Clark, Lois and Jon, though there's sadly very little of it in this volume.

     In the end this third volume of Superman is a relative low point in Tomasi and Gleason's run. The overarching story is stalled and, unlike the last volume, the individual stories told here feel pretty inconsequential and dramatically inert. There are nice moments and the art is pretty solid overall but this volume is pretty skip-able when it's all said and done.

Score: 6/10

Friday, June 29, 2018

Potential Q&A Video Anouncement

I've reached 1,000 subscribers on YouTube (it's not really a big deal, especially since most of them subscribed as a result of the Superman vs. the Elite end scene video). To celebrate I may try to do an Q&A if I can generate enough interest. With that said, if anyone still following this blog has any questions they liked to ask me, leave them in the comments section here or on the video. If I get enough I will try to do a Q&A sometime next week.

With that said, I'm trying to figure out how I will approach it. I may just video myself with my phone like I've been doing but I'm also considering using a nicer camera or maybe doing some sort of Let's Play with an old game as I respond to questions, as I've been trying to get back into gaming (though not very successfully).


Wednesday, June 27, 2018

Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom (2018) Review (Video)

I'm hoping to do these more often now. WARNING: MAJOR SPOILERS... 


A few things I missed:
1) It's revealed that Mills (the evil business guy) has been developing the Indoraptor in the basement of James Cromwell's mansion. I find it incredibly hard to believe that no one noticed this.

2) The film is basically a loose remaking of The Lost World, but we spend less time on the island and end in the mansion instead of in San Diego.

3) I forgot that one likable character does die (I actually talk about this in the video), but he is not killed by a dinosaur.

Score: 5/10

Saturday, June 23, 2018

Saturday Evening Cartoons: Incredibles 2 (2018) (Video)

I decided to do a short video review of Incredibles 2...


There are a few things I forgot to mention in the video that I'd like to add:

1) I saw the villain plot coming a mile away. I'm not sure if this is the film's fault or if I've just seen to many movies. It's probably a bit of both.

2) The offending line from Mr. Incredible which I allude to in the video is basically him implying that he only wants Helen to win the public's trust back so that he, not his family or his friends, can be a superhero again. This seems to me to go against his arc in the first movie, which was learning to put his family first. It's also never addressed again after this. It's possible that I took it the wrong way and that Brad Bird meant this to be a Freudian slip on Bob's part, revealing a deep seated desire that he is, correctly, trying to keep in check. As I said it simply rubbed me the wrong way.

Finally, as it's my usual practice and I neglected to do so in the video I will rate the film.

Score: 7/10

Wednesday, June 20, 2018

Western Wednesdays: Cimarron (1931)

     Cimarron was released on February 9th, 1931. Directed by Wesley Ruggles and based on the novel by Edna Ferber (Giant, Showboat) it was the first western film to win Best Picture at the Academy Awards (this would not occur again until Dances With Wolves won the award in 1990). In it Yancey Cravat (Richard Dix) makes his fortune in Osage, a booming town in the Oklahoma Territory in the late 1800's, helping to bring civilization to the wilderness.

     Being an early sound picture, Cimarron is a little dated in certain respects. Like many films from this period the performances are highly theatrical. Many film-makers did not how what to do with the new element of sound and they looked to theatre for inspiration, especially in regards to the acting. So the acting in films from this period often featured exaggerated gestures and loud, sonorous dialogue delivery. While these kinds of performance work on the stage, where you have to get your feelings across to someone on the other side of a room, it does not lend itself well to film. This movie also has some characters who are racial stereotypes, particularly Yancey's black servant boy, portrayed by Eugene Jackson. There are also some strange editing choices in the first half of the film.

     Cimarron is less disingenuous and more folksy then later entries in the genre. It is not weighed down by the years of mythologizing and philosophical moral questions about the necessity of violence or the corruption of civilization that would mark so many famous westerns. This film assumes that establishing civilization to the wilderness is a good thing and that violence is sometimes necessary in order to accomplish this. But it's also a more progressive film then I expected, especially in its treatment of White/Indian relations. There's a scene early in the film where Yancey is giving a speech in a church and declares, "If you knew anything at all, you'd realize that a Cherokee is too smart to put anything in the contribution box of a race that's robbed him of his birthright." A strong statement for a film released 60 years before Dances with Wolves.

     This film is epic in scope. Opening with an awesome portrayal of the 1889 Oklahoma gold-rush, the films chronicles Yancey Cravat's rise to power over the proceeding 2 decades. He is shown to be a progressively minded individual. Aside from his previously alluded to sympathy for the plight of Native Americans he also stands up for a local prostitute, Dixie Lee (Estelle Taylor), one who the film hilariously avoids referring to that way (this is incredibly tame for a pre-code film), going so far as to defend her in court when the town tries to run her out for her illicit business despite his wife's objections.

     Yancey's relationship with his wife Sabra (Irene Dunne) is a problematic element in the film. He leaves her, multiple times, in order to go out and seek adventure. There's nothing wrong with this on its own, the call of the wilderness is a common trope in the genre, but the film seems completely sympathetic to him despite his abandonment of his family. Sabra herself is portrayed as something of a bigot through much of the film. Showing prejudice toward the Cherokee and against Dixie Lee. By the end of the film, largely through Yancey's sympathy for them, she has become more progressive in her outlook and the film closes with her becoming the first female congresswoman.

     Cimarron is not a great film. It's held back by overly theatrical performances, an uncritical view of its flawed protagonist and occasional racial stereotypes but it is a really unique western, and one worth checking out for its historical significance and epic scope if nothing else.

Score: 7/10

Saturday, June 16, 2018

My Favorite Films: The Incredibles (2004) (Saturday Evening Cartoons)

     The Incredibles may be the most perfect superhero movie ever made. Not the most influential, though it is influential and I wish it was more so, not the most ambitious, though it is quite ambitious, but the one with the tightest screenplay. As much as I love films like Superman, Spider-Man 2 and The Dark Knight, all three of these movies have moments of weak writing but not The Incredibles.

     The world of The Incredibles is somewhat inspired by Alan Moore's Watchmen albeit far more optimistic and upbeat. Once inhabited by powerful superheroes, increasing public scrutiny of their actions has caused the government to initiate a relocation program, causing them to adhere to their secret identities. It opens with a brilliant flashback sequence, told in the style of old "On the March" newsreels, showing various superheroes being interviewed. In a moment that will later seem ironic, showing the unpredictability of life, Mr. Incredible (Craig T. Nelson) states his desire to settle down and raise a family, while Elastigirl (Holly Hunter) shrugs off a similar suggestion, "Leave the saving of the world to the men? I don't think so." Soon after, we see her and Mr. Incredible exchanging vows.

     The film then cuts to many years later. Mr. Incredible and Elastigirl (now known exclusively as Bob and Helen Parr) have since had three children, Violet (Sarah Vowell), Dash (Spencer Fox) and Jack-Jack (Eli Fucile and Maeve Andrews), and are living a peaceful domestic life in the Metroville. But all is not well. The family is constrained by the societal intolerance of superpowers, unable to use them in public. Bob, in particular, is deeply frustrated by this and he goes through something of a midlife crisis over the course of the film. He longs to "play superhero" again, to relive his exciting, glorious past. Partly this comes from an innate desire to help people. He is constantly getting in trouble at Insuricare, the insurance agency he works for, because he can't help but give needy clients a hand in navigating their insurance, much to the consternation of his overbearing, demeaning boss Gilbert Huph (played by Wallace Shawn).

     But he also simply enjoys the rush, the thrill of taking down bad guys and saving people from danger. He is often heedless of the consequences, or collateral damage this might cause. This is of course what lead to the circumstances he and the other supers find themselves in in the first place. At the beginning of the story we see that he is moonlighting as a vigilante along with his old friend Frozone (Samuel L. Jackson) and hiding this from his wife. In general, Bob is somewhat neglectful of his family. In an early scene where the family is having dinner he is preoccupied, not listening as his wife tells him that their son Dash (Spencer Fox) has gotten in trouble in school. Then he gets fired from his job after loosing his temper with Mr. Huph.

     This puts him in a really difficult position. How will he be able to support his family now? With all of this stress and frustration, Bob jumps at the chance to bring back the good old days when he receives a call from a mysterious woman named Mirage (Elizabeth Pena), offering him a large sum of money if he will resume his role as Mr. Incredible and destroy a rogue robot called the Omnidroid on the remote island of Nomanisan. Once again he hides all of this from Helen, pretending instead that he is going on a business trip for Insuricare.

     After defeating the robot, Bob's life gets better for a time. With the money he earned he buys a new car and is able to spend more time with his family. He also starts working out again, having gotten out of shape in his years as an insurance agent. But it all inevitably falls apart. Helen notices that Bob's old super suit has been ripped and patched up, and she goes to costume designer Edna Mode (voiced by Brad Bird himself) for answers. Edna, who did the patch job for Bob and has also designed brand new super suits for him and his family reveals this to Helen, and gives her a tracker which she placed on Bob's suit. Meanwhile Bob has returned to Nomanisan for another job but he is unexpectedly attacked by a new and improved Omnidroid and it is revealed that his employer is Buddy Pine, a former fan who Mr. Incredible angered by refusing to let him be his sidekick.

     Buddy is a somewhat atypical villain. A sort of Tim Drake gone wrong, his adulation of Mr. Incredible turns into disdain for the entire superhero community after being rejected by him. His plan is to kill all of the former superheroes by offering them the same deal he gave Bob, only to have them destroyed by the Omnidroid. With this accomplished he plans to send the robot to attack Metroville and then use his tech to defeat it, becoming the world's one and only superhero: Syndrome. He's also a representation of Bob's central character flaw, namely his lack of emotional openness. By treating Buddy in a terse, cold manner, he inadvertently created Syndrome.

     Using Edna's tracking beacon, Helen tracks Bob to the island, and Violet and Dash stow away on her plane. On entering the island's airspace they are shot down by Buddy's minions, and act witnessed by the captured Mr. Incredible. Seeing this nearly breaks Bob. Suddenly his whole world has been taken from him. In his rage he threatens to kill Mirage, but Buddy calls his bluff and Mr. Incredible lets her go. Despite his anger he can't commit murder. This experience helps Bob to realize his own failings, he has now seemingly lost the the thing his life revolves around. Its only at this point that he discovers how much his family means to him. When he discovers that they survived the crash and reunites with Helen, he is overjoyed. His character arc is completed when he admits his failings to his family, "You are my greatest adventure. And I almost missed it." He has realized that it is not just being strong that makes him fulfilled, it's being strong for his family.

     The Incredibles is all about family. Not just the idea of a family (as in the Fast and Furious or Guardians of the Galaxy movies, which explore the idea of a surrogate family as a substitute for the real thing) but the hard work and sacrifice necessary to have one. Bob is the central protagonist and the film is focused on his arc but all of the Parr family grow and change throughout the film.

     Helen wants nothing more then to live a happy domestic life with her family. She is not happy about the government relocation program but is willing to make the best of it. She is deeply frustrated with her husband, who seems stuck in the past. Helen is the ultimate supermom. Raising a family is all the more exasperating when two of your children have superpowers and she has to stretch herself (literally and figuratively) to hold the family together. But she's overextending herself, wearing herself thin. On Syndrome's island she is forced to rely on her kids, to let them use their own powers to help each other survive.

     Dash is a prepubescent superhero who has never really had the chance to explore his powers. This causes him to become extremely frustrated, frustration he takes out on his teacher at school and on his sister Violet. Once he is put in a position where he has to use his powers he is at first overwhelmed and a little scared. But it ends up being an incredibly cathartic experience and Dash learns that he is more powerful then he ever imagined. But he also learns to better control his super speed and to use it in a more responsible manner.

     Violet on the other hand is an incredibly shy and vulnerable teenage girl. She is attracted to a boy at school, Tony, but can't summon up the courage to talk to him. Her powers (invisibility and creating shields) reflect this. She is generally ashamed of her powers and wishes she were "normal". Through her experience on the island she gains a great deal of confidence and self reliance and she learns to appreciate her powers as a gift instead of a curse. By the end of the film she is able to ask Tony out on a date.

     Even Jack-Jack, a relative blank slate throughout most of the movie, goes through a change when his powers manifest for the first time. Defeated and humiliated by the Parrs, Syndrome tries to kidnap their youngest child, but Jack-Jack shape-shifts into a series of different, crazy forms, and Syndrome, taken by surprise, lets him go. Through the events of the film the entire family is brought closer together and becomes stronger as a result.

      The film expertly blends comedy and drama. Brad Bird has said that he wanted to juxtapose the extraordinary with the mundane and this is the film's main source of comic relief. Throughout the film there are many scenes where an extraordinary feat is undercut with a moment of mundanity, of everyday, real world problems, like when Mr. Incredible dislocates his back while fighting the Omnidroid. Rather then deflating the tension or drama these moments serve to ground the film and the characters in reality and actually makes the action feel more dangerous and believable.

     The animation was a huge breakthrough for Pixar at the time. They had given life to inanimate objects like toys and to animals like ants and fish, but they had yet to make a film with really amazing human characters. The Incredibles would be the first. The sense of movement in the animation, of weight and physicality, was unprecedented. The film's technical team really had to struggle to create hair, fabric and muscles that looked convincing and worked in a way that was visually believable and they knocked it out of the park. The characters' facial and physical mannerisms are all really expressive, bringing the characters Bird wrote to life. Little moments like Helen's exasperated sigh while sweeping the floor make the characters feel grounded and human. The sets, many of which recall Ken Adam's work on the early James Bond films, are amazingly detailed and the world of the film always feel organic and alive as a result.

     The executives at Disney were, at first, reluctant to produce this film as its story, according to conventional wisdom, seems better suited to live action. Yet The Incredibles makes great use of the limitless potential of the medium. The characters, as I've already emphasized, feel real yet they don't look realistic. They look like exaggerated cartoon characters, very similar to the art style of Brad Bird's first feature, The Iron Giant. A lot of credit has to go to Bird, not only for keeping the production together while letting the animators, storyboard artists, and the rest of the crew contribute and be creative, but also for adding his own unique voice and sensibilities to the film and staying true to his original vision. He wanted to approach the film in a more cinematic way then is usual for animation, using moody lighting and varying the focal length, whereas most animated films exclusively use deep focus. This helps to give the film a really cinematic quality.

     The film is also perfectly paced, taking the time to set up the characters and their world. It doesn't let the action overwhelm the story, setting aside plenty of time for the dramatic moments. The action scenes are built up to in an organic and natural way and once they start it's well worth the wait. They are all expertly crafted. The great thing about action in animated movies is that has to be completely planned and carefully story-boarded beforehand. This usually results in action scenes where the geography is very clear. We always understand where the characters are in relation to each other and we get a clear picture of what everyone is doing. But more then that, this film does a great job making creative use of each character's unique power set and allowing them to work off each other in an organic, flowing way. It rivals the best action set-pieces in live action superhero films. Finally, these action scenes don't feel obligatory or forced, rather they further the plot and serve to bring our characters together. When Bob and Helen come to the rescue of Dash and Violet on the island, we see the family function as a unit for the first time. And when Dash runs away from Syndrome's hovercraft, he is able to tap into his power like never before.

     Micheal Giachinno's score perfectly captures the film's retro vibe. While jazzy in timbre, the score recalls music from 60s spy and crime thrillers like James Bond, Peter Gunn, and Mission Impossible, the score still retains a strong sense of leitmotif, and is both unique and memorable as a result. It also wonderfully accentuates the drama, tension, action and humor of the film, adding an extra layer of emotional resonance without drawing too much attention to itself. The sound design in general is simply fantastic and the film received a much deserved Oscar nomination for Randy Thom's sound mixing.

     The same can be said of the films voice acting. Craig T. Nelson and Holly Hunter imbue Bob and Helen Parr with a great deal of energy, personality and humanity and the two have great chemistry together. Sarah Powell and Spencer Fox are also great as Violet and Dash. As voiced by Jason Lee, Syndrome (who he voices both as a kid and an adult) is an overgrown, manic geek yet he has this underlying sense of menace and deep seated resentment. Samuel L. Jackson is doing his usual thing as Frozone. He's supremely confident and cool yet also has this explosive temper. Wallace Shawn (The Princess Bride) is perfectly cast as Bob's diminutive boss, Mr. Huph and Elizabeth Pena adds a dash a mystery and also a certain dignity to Mirage. But it's Brad Bird who steals the show as Edna Mode. Equal parts Edith Head and Q from James Bond, Edna's bizarre Japanese/German inflection could only be produced by Bird. She steals every scene she's in and Bird knows to use her just enough, so it never becomes obnoxious or annoying.

     It may surprise some people to find out that I didn't see The Incredibles in theaters, given my predilection both for animation and for movies about superheroes. After all I was the perfect age (11 years old) when it was released. Unfortunately (and my long time readers know this already) Sci-Fi and fantasy, and most modern media in general, was mostly taboo in my house when I was young. However, I'd like to think that if my parents had taken me and my siblings to see this film they might have been pleasantly surprised.

     The Incredibles is one of the few modern blockbusters with a really strong, positive portrayal of the nuclear family. Bob and Helen make mistakes but both try their hardest to care for and protect their children. The world around them makes this difficult. The exceptional is frowned upon and, to paraphrase Mr. Incredible, the mediocre is celebrated. Syndrome is, in a way, the ultimate expression of this sentiment. After removing all the supers and becoming the world's one-and-only hero he plans to sell his inventions to the rest of humanity, so that everyone can be a superhero. "And when everyone's super, no one will be." But the family is ultimately able to triumph despite these difficulties. Beyond this, the film really takes time to show those common, everyday problems families go through. Arguments around the dinner table, parental discord, trying to hold on to a dead-end job to support your family, The Incredibles highlights all of these problems and it is that much more relatable and resonant as a result.

     The Incredibles changed the game for computer animation. Its airtight screenplay is bolstered by creative, energetic direction from Brad Bird, stunning animation from the team at Pixar and a really solid voice cast, and all of this is at the service of a really relatable, human story about maintaining a family in this frenetic day and age. It's not just one of my favorite superhero movies or animated films it's one of my favorite films period.

Monday, June 4, 2018

Musical Mondays: The Pirate (1948)

 
     The Pirate was released on May 20th, 1948. It is directed by Vincent Minnelli (Meet Me in St. Louis) with songs by the legendary Cole Porter. In it Manuela Alva's (Judy Garland) plan to marry Don Pedro (Walter Slezak), the mayor of her small Caribbean hometown of Calvados, are interrupted when the leader of a traveling circus named Serafin (Gene Kelly) falls in love with her and schemes to woo her away from Don Pedro. On discovering that Don Juan is actually the legendary pirate Macoco, who Manuela dreams of being wooed by, Serafin blackmails the phony mayor and pretends to be the Macoco himself.

     This film had a really troubled production history. The script, by Frances Goodrich, went through several rewrites before the film entered production and one musical number had to be cut from the film and replaced when executives at MGM deemed it overly sexual during a test screening. The footage of this number was reportedly burned at the request of studio head Louis B. Mayer and no footage of it is known to exist today. Judy Garland's struggles with drug addiction and frequent angry confrontations with director Vincent Minnelli, at the time her husband, lead to her being off-set for much of the production and it was delayed as a result. Bad reactions to audience test screenings then caused the film to be re-edited. The film would ultimately flop at the box office, losing over 2 million dollars for MGM.

     With all of this behind-the-scenes drama, you might expect the film to be a bit of a mess. In some ways this is true. The story, though interesting falls apart in the third act. Manuela has a deep seated, almost Freudian attraction toward Macoco (or at least the idea that she has of him in her head). The fact that Serafin, after discovering this, tries to use it to manipulate her is rather despicable as is his attempt to hypnotize her and his general attitude of "she must be attracted to me." Because of this I found her initial attitude toward him, one of annoyance and disdain, refreshing, at least until she falls in love with him for no apparent reason. The problem is not that Serafin isn't sufficiently punished for his actions, he is almost hanged after all, it's just that he needs to do more to make it up to her and it all just feels to fast. The pacing in general is a little off, probably a result of the re-editing. It takes almost ten minutes before we get to the first musical number and, because some of the songs were cut, we hear songs that are meant to be reprises but now have to function on there own.

     Despite this I still liked the film. The story mainly functions as a vehicle to string together the musical number and, fortunately, there really, really good here. Gene Kelly is so magnetic in this movie, so charismatic, athletic, graceful and comical that he immediately elevates any scene he's in and this goes double whenever singing and dancing is involved. From the burlesque, Latin flavor of "Niña" to the outrageous antics of "Be a Clown" Cole Porters songs for The Pirate are all unique, memorable and witty. The sets and costumes are just/simply beautiful and cinematographer Harry Stradling Sr. captures them really well. Robert Alton's choreography is brilliant and makes full use of both Kelly and Garland's talents. Vincent Minnelli directs the film with real panache, effortlessly using long takes and keeping everything together despite all of the drama happening off-camera.

     In the end, The Pirate is a messy film but one with a lot of production value. It's clear when watching it how much hard work and passion went into it. In the end I think it works, despite it flaws.

Score: 7/10

Saturday, June 2, 2018

Saturday Evening Cartoons: Superman, Volume 2: Trials of the Super Son

It's an exciting time to be a Superman fan. The character is celebrating his 80th anniversary this year and there's a lot going on with his character, both in comics and elsewhere. The 1000th issue of Action Comics was released last month to much fanfare. A new movie adaptation of The Death of Superman is set to be released later this year. Meanwhile Brian Micheal Bendis, after his recent departure from Marvel Comics, is set to start writing both Superman and Action Comics after the completion of a miniseries, The Man of Steel, the first issue of which was released this past week. Finally, Peter J. Tomasi and Patrick Gleason have completed their run on Superman. Which brings me to my point. With all of this going on I figured this would be an opportune time to review the rest of their run (I reviewed the first volume last year).

     Superman, Volume 2: Trials of the Super Son is essentially a collection of short stories. To be honest, in this age of serialized storytelling, I find this approach really refreshing. In the first story, Our Town, we see Clark accompany Lois and Jon to the Hamilton County fair. While there he prevents a robbery, must to Lois' consternation, as he promised her there would be no super-heroics. This is a fun little story and its nice to see Clark interacting with his family. However, the main source of tension, Superman trying to avoid suiting up so he can spend time with his family, doesn't really work for me. Surely Lois doesn't expect her husband to stand idly by while the robbers take the entry money for the fair, and potentially hurt the ticket agents? Her impatience with him is meant to be endearing but I don't really buy it.

     In the second arc, Escape from Dinosaur Island, Superman and Superboy are transported to Dinosaur Island where they meet Captain Storm, one of The Losers, a team of WWII soldiers created by Robert Kanigher in the 1960's. We learn that Storm is the only surviving member of the team, the others having perished in their mission to the island. Its a really fun story, I mean who doesn't want to see Superman fight dinosaurs and giant ape monsters. It's also a fitting tribute to Darwyn Cook who, in his out-of-continuity DC: The New Frontier, had The Losers killed off during a mission to Dinosaur Island to rescue Rick Flag. Cooke passed away from cancer a few months before the story was published and it serves as a nice tribute to one of our generations most unique and vital creators.

     The third arc, In the Name of the Father: World's Smallest, serves as a set-up for the Super Sons ongoing series, focusing on Jon and Damien Wayne. In it we find out that Damien has been spying on Jon behind his father's back. He and Clark decide to help the two boys become friends by putting them through a sort of "training camp." This is really the main arc of this volume, the one that moves the overall story forward the most and it's pretty well done. Jon and Damien's very different personalities and attitudes create a lot of natural drama but I also buy it when they eventually work together and become friends (or frenemies to borrow an annoying modern term). There also some, more subtle, growth in Superman's relationship with Batman. Ever since the 52 version of Superman was killed in The Last Days of Superman, Batman has mistrusted this new (or older, I guess?) version of the character. Throughout the early issues of Tomasi's run we see them begin to form a trusting relationship. This will end up becoming irrelevant due to some retconning later on, but oh well.

     In the last story arc, Super-Monster, it is revealed that Candice, an editor who has offered Lois a job writing for the Hamilton Horn, is actually an alien fugitive named Kroog, who Frankenstein, Agent of S.H.A.D.E. is searching for. A conflict breaks out when The Bride of Frankenstein, now a bounty hunter, shows up to collect the bounty on Kroog. In the confusion, Kroog escapes. We learn that Frankenstein and the Bride broke up after she was forced to kill their son, who went on a murderous rampage. Ultimately, Frankenstein allows her to take Kroog and collect the bounty, hoping to win her back but she rejects him. This story is a bit of a mixed bag. On the one hand I like the relationship between Frankenstein and the Bride and the way Tomasi frames it as a tragic mirror of Clark and Lois' marriage, giving them a greater appreciation for what they have. On the other hand some of the conflict feels a bit contrived, especially considering how easy it is all resolved in the end.

Jorge Jimenez's art for Superman #7
     For this volume the different teams of artists were assigned to different stories, making for a more cohesive read then the first volume, which featured jarring shifts in the art style in the middle of a story. The first story was drawn by Jorge Jiménez with colors by Alejandro Sanchez. Jimenez is not a bad artist, but a lot of his work here looks a little rushed, with some sloppy facial work. Both Escape from Dinosaur Island and Super-Monster feature pencils by Doug Mahnke and inks by Jaime Mendoza (along with Trevor Scott on the former and Keith Champagne, Norm Rapmundand and Christian Alamy on the latter) with coloring by Wil Quintana. This art is, generally pretty strong and Mahnke handles the over-the-top action scenes really well. Finally, In the Name of the Father: World's Smallest was penciled by Patrick Gleason with inks by Mick Gray, Mark Morales and Christian Alamy and coloring by John Kalisz. This art is the strongest of the run as Tomasi and Gleason clearly have a really strong working relationship. They do some interesting things with the panels contrasting the more wild action beats with the more standard plotted dialogue scenes.

     Overall, Superman, Volume 2: Trials of the Super Son is a fun read. While some of the stories are better than others there all worth reading and the art work is more consistent then the first volume. Nothing super important happens, continuity wise but for me that's kind of a plus.

Score: 8/10