Western Wednesdays: A Coffin for the Sheriff (1965)

     A Coffin for the Sheriff was released on December 23rd, 1965. Directed by Mario Caiano and written by David Moreno and Guido Malatesta it stars Anthony Steffen as Shenandoah, a drifter who joins up with a band of outlaws in his pursuit of vengeance for his wife, who was raped and murdered by one of their number. 

     A Coffin for the Sheriff is a very uneven film. Some scenes are rather inspired: Shenandoah's initiation into the gang which involves a cat and mouse with one of the bandits, where the latter is given twelve bullets and Shenandoah only one, and the climax where he stalks his wife's killer through the streets of Richmond. Unfortunately, much of the film is plodding and predictable and the script is incredibly stilted, even by genre standards. It is also tonally inconsistent at times, with the comic relief (mostly supplied by Jesús Tordesillas' anonymous old man) clashing with the films dark, violent story. 

     Director Mario Caiano, whose first western, Bullets Don't Argue, was an uninspired rip-off of American westerns, takes this film in a much more dark and brutal direction. The scene where Shenandoah is beat by the gang after they discover his true motives lives up to the genre's usual sadistic standards and the attempted rape of Luciana Gilli's Jane Wilson is, in particular, hard to watch. If nothing else, Caiano was skilled at directing action scenes and this film has some good ones. The aforementioned climax is a highlight as is the furious shootout which precedes it. Earlier scenes, where the bandits flee the town after a robbery and where they attack Wilson's (George Rigaud) ranch are also well done. 

     Anthony Steffen is solid in the lead role. He plays it stoically through most of the film but really comes alive near the end, when the identity of his wife's killer is revealed. Eduardo Fajardo is practically dripping with evil as the murderer Murdock while Armando Calvo brings his own sense of menace to Lupe Rojo, the leader of the gang. Arturo Dominici brings plenty of sleaze to Jerry Krueger, the cowardly lawyer turned bandit. María Vico imbues Lupe's much abused mistress with a real sense of pathos and bitterness while Luciana Gilli gives the otherwise wilting Jane Wilson a spirited streak. Her father on the other hand, as portrayed by George Rigaud seems peculiarly indifferent through most of the proceedings. 

     In the end, A Coffin for the Sheriff is a thoroughly routine and at times rather crude spaghetti western. It is worth checking out for its action scenes and its suspenseful climax. 

Score: 6/10